Decision details

Tree Management

Decision Maker: Environment, Economic Growth and Transport Scrutiny Committee

Decision status: Recommendations Approved

Is Key decision?: No

Purpose:

The report will provide the Committee with information relating to:
• Current policy on tree management and replacement.
• How the council plants trees.
• Available funding.
• Data on trees planted and removed.

Decisions:

The Chair welcomed John Davies, Interim Director of Highways and Transport, and Paul Binks, Asset Manager (Highways – Principal Engineer), to the meeting. The report provided the committee with information relating to the current policy on tree management and replacement, how the council planted trees, available funding and data on trees planted and removed. A presentation to complement the report was provided at the meeting and a copy is set out in the minute book.

 

A summary of the discussion at the meeting is set out below.

 

•  Routine works such as crown lifting and the removal of epicormic growth were not generally undertaken as a matter of course. However, where a concern was reported, or identified by an inspector, it would be assessed and, where appropriate, a works order raised.

•  The county council did not have a general budget for planting trees within the highway. Highway tree planting was currently undertaken where it was funded through a specific project, such as a public realm improvement scheme.

•  When trees formed part of wider public realm improvement schemes, the method and location of planting, including the possible use of containers or other planting arrangements, would be considered as part of the design of the scheme.

•  Tree root pits were used to restrict the extent to which roots could spread and added to the overall cost of planting a tree within the highway.

•  The quoted cost of approximately £2,000 to £10,000 related to planting an individual, substantial tree in a restricted highway location and did not represent the cost of all tree planting. Smaller trees or saplings planted could cost considerably less.

•  The county council had an officer who specifically dealt with Section 154 notices concerning privately owned trees presenting a highway safety issue. The owner could be required to undertake the necessary work and, if they failed to do so, the county council could undertake the work itself. Recovery of the costs from the owner could, however, present difficulties.

•  The allocation for addressing tree defects in 2026/27 was three times the amount available in previous years and formed part of wider safety-defect funding.

•  The volume of tree safety work had increased significantly, particularly as a consequence of ash dieback, requiring the available resources to be prioritised according to risk.

•  Tree works were undertaken on a risk-based approach. In exceptional cases requiring immediate action, emergency traffic management could be introduced and a tree removed within 24 hours. Other works could be assigned timescales of one, three, six or twelve months depending upon the assessed risk.

•  Current resources were focused predominantly on the most urgent safety works, particularly those requiring action within one month. Works allocated a three-to-six-month timescale could be reassessed to establish whether the condition or level of risk had deteriorated.

•  Tree works were undertaken using a combination of county council staff and external contractors, and the contractual arrangements for this work had been reviewed.

•  Following the removal of an unsafe tree, subsequent works such as stump removal and stump grinding could be requested. These works were generally undertaken by contractors and grouped together for delivery.

•  It was suggested that a recommendation be put to Cabinet on the creation of a separate budget to address accessibility issues and acknowledged that it would be useful to establish the number and scale of requests involving footways affected by tree roots, including raised or uneven paving, to provide a clearer picture of the extent of the issues.

•  It was felt that any funding for replacement tree planting would need to be separate from the tree safety budget, so that expenditure on replacement planting did not compete with works necessary to address identified safety risks.

•  It was acknowledged that the scale of accessibility and other non-emergency tree-related works would first need to be established so that any proposed budget could appropriately reflect the level of need. The timing of the discussion was considered appropriate as the county council was approaching its budget-setting process, with the wider budgets going to Full Council in February 2027 and the individual Highways Capital Programme being considered in March.

•  The county council had been shortlisted for a National Forest bid. If successful in progressing further, this could result in substantial investment in Lancashire and potentially enable planting on a scale greater than anticipated losses from ash dieback and other causes.

•  When selecting trees for highway locations, it was confirmed that consideration was given to the species and suitability of the location, applying the principle of the right species in the right place. It was acknowledged that, with current knowledge, some species used in previous highway planting schemes would not now be selected because of the problems they could cause.

 

In formulating recommendations, it was;

 

 

Resolved: That;

 

(i)  The Environment, Economic Growth and Transport Scrutiny Committee recognised that the removal of danger is paramount and that the Cabinet Member for Highways and Transport gives consideration to:

 

a.  Increasing the budget allocation to adequately address urgent and emergency works.

 

b.  Introducing a separate budget to address lower priority work, for example because of accessibility, amenity, drainage issues and issues with self-seeded trees in hedgerows (cutting back/removal).

 

(ii)  The Cabinet Member for Rural Affairs, Environment and Communities gives consideration to:

 

a.  Taking advantage of new National Forestry funding and become part of the Northern Forest.

 

b.  Encouraging volunteer micro forest planting across the county council area.

 

(iii) The Environment, Economic Growth and Transport Scrutiny Committee recognised the value of trees in the urban treescape and the benefit in terms of mitigating a warming climate and the provision of shade in town centres and that the Cabinet Member for Highways and Transport considers the introduction of a budget for tree replacement with a system of prioritisation.

 

Corporate Priorities : Economic ambition;

Divisions Affected: (All Divisions);

Contact: Paul Binks Email: paul.binks@lancashire.gov.uk Tel: 01772 532210.

Report author: Paul Binks

Date of decision: 17/09/2026

Decided at meeting: 17/09/2026 - Environment, Economic Growth and Transport Scrutiny Committee

Accompanying Documents: